Image for article titled Why You Shouldn't Buy Apple's MagSafe Battery Pack for iPhone 12

There are times Apple knocks it out of the park with its accessories. AirPods, for example, provide a better experience than other Bluetooth headphones. But there are times that Apple’s own first-party accessories fall short of what’s available from third-party manufactures, like the case of Apple’s $99 magnetic MagSafe Battery Pack for iPhone 12.

How MagSafe Battery Pack for iPhone 12 works

The MagSafe Battery Pack is a rectangular battery pack (or power bank) that attaches magnetically to the back of the iPhone 12, 12 mini, 12 Pro, and 12 Pro Max. It costs $99. It works like any other MagSafe accessory, and as a first-party battery pack, it has an integrated experience that no other product has. It’s the only battery pack or accessory to support reverse wireless charging—meaning that you can charge the battery pack while charging the iPhone (the battery pack will only start charging after your iPhone is charged up to 80%). The battery pack itself charges using a Lightning cable.

Why the MagSafe Battery Pack is such a disappointment

If you only look at the MagSafe experience, it sounds pretty good, but the devil is in the details that Apple doesn’t readily provide on the product page. It starts with the capacity: The MagSafe Battery Pack has a 1460 mAh, 11.13Wh battery inside, which is tiny. In comparison, the iPhone 12 itself has a 10.78Wh battery. Also, consider that Qi wireless charging is inefficient, with quite a bit of capacity lost just in the charging process. Not to mention the fact that the battery pack only charges the iPhone at 5W, which is pretty slow.

All of this translates to the MagSafe Battery Pack struggling to charge your iPhone fully, and even when it does charge it up to 90%, it’s going to take a hell of a long time.

What Apple does have going for it is the fact that they’re using an 11Wh battery (which is double the capacity of third-party battery packs). This puts the real capacity at 2920 mAh, but that’s still not enough to fully charge an iPhone 12 considering the power loss in the wireless charging process.

Granted, there is a way to fast charge your iPhone using the MagSafe Battery Pack, but that’s using a 20W adapter via the Lightning port (essentially using the battery pack as a wireless charger). Oh, and it doesn’t come with an adapter or a cable in the box.

The MagSafe Battery Pack also has some of the same usability issues as the MagSafe Wallet. While the magnets are strong when attached (you can’t simply shake it off), a simple nudge from your thumb is enough to dislodge the magnets, which isn’t good news for an accessory that will be going in and out of your pockets all day. Ultimately, while the marketing images for the MagSafe Battery Pack show quite a sleek product, the reality is different.

Cheaper alternatives to the MagSafe Battery Pack

Image for article titled Why You Shouldn't Buy Apple's MagSafe Battery Pack for iPhone 12

Realistically, the MagSafe Battery Pack can only charge your iPhone up to 70-90%, depending on your model, and not fast charging. If you don’t mind using third-party alternatives, you can get better performance (like a full charge), for cheaper (sometimes less than half the price).

These battery packs are only MagSafe compatible (essentially just Qi wireless chargers with magnets), so they won’t get extra features like better power efficiency of MagSafe charging, but because the MagSafe Battery Pack itself is limited to 5W charging, you’re not losing out on much.

Here are some alternatives to consider:

  • HyperJuice ($39.99): This is one of the most popular and reliable magnetic battery pack. It has a 5000 mAh battery and supports 7.5W wireless charging (12W wired charging using a USB-C port).
  • Mophie snap+ juice pack mini ($49.99): A similar story here, also rated at 5000 mAh and can fully charge an iPhone 12. There’s a USB-C port for charging the battery pack.
  • Anker PowerCore Magnetic 5K ($45.99): Anker’s PowerCore Magnetic 5K is another battery pack from a reputable brand. It’s a similar package to Mophie’s and has a 5000 mAh battery inside. It’s rated to fully charge the iPhone 12 mini, and it will almost fully charge the iPhone 12 and 12 Pro (95% to 97%). It will only charge the iPhone 12 Pro Max to 75%.

Why you still might want a MagSafe Battery Pack

All that considered, you might still want to get one. It is, after all, the only real MagSafe Battery Pack on the market. It has tight integration with iOS, its battery health management features, and it is easy to use. All you have to do is snap it on your iPhone and you can forget about it. If that’s worth the $99 asking price, the rest of the devilish details don’t have to stop you.

 




https://lifehacker.com/why-you-shouldnt-buy-apples-magsafe-battery-pack-for-ip-1847333662